I've been punting long enough to know the shiny welcome offers mean bugger all once you've had a proper go on a site. What matters to me now is the stuff you only find out after a few months — how they handle withdrawals, whether the odds are still decent close to kickoff, if the app turns to mush on a busy Saturday arvo, and how trigger-happy they are with limits.
A couple I used to rate have gone a bit downhill lately. Plenty of noise in the promos, then you actually compare prices and they're nothing special... or you finally jag a decent collect and suddenly every bet you place gets chopped to crumbs. Verification is another one. I don't mind doing the usual checks, but some sites make it feel like you're dealing with Centrelink just to get your own cash out.
For me the good ones are pretty simple: easy to use, fair enough on same game multis, live betting that doesn't lag like crazy, and support that doesn't vanish the second something goes wrong. Bonus bets are nice, sure, but I'd rather have a reliable bookie than a flashy one.
Keen to hear what everyone else is sticking with these days for NRL, AFL, racing, whatever. Who's been solid for you lately, and who's turned into more hassle than they're worth? Chuck in the good and the ugly — proper punter feedback is way more useful than the polished stuff.