Been punting online long enough now that the welcome offers barely register for me. What usually tells me if a bookie is worth keeping is the boring stuff nobody bangs on about in the ads — how fast the app loads on a busy Saturday arvo, whether they chop your limits after one decent weekend, if cash-outs are smooth, and how painful they get when you try to verify or pull money out.
For me the big separators are pricing on AFL/NRL, how usable the same game multi builder is, and whether live markets stay up when things get hectic. A few look good for the first couple of weeks then turn into hard work... promos with ten catches, odds that are always a touch short, support taking forever, that sort of gear. If a place is solid with deposits and withdrawals and not mucking you around, I'm way more likely to stick around.
Keen to hear what everyone else rates these days. Not asking for a lazy "who's best" answer, more the stuff that actually matters once you've used a few of them properly. Which ones have been reliable for you lately, and which ones went downhill fast?