Been around a fair few bookies over the years and I reckon the stuff that keeps me on a site now is pretty different to what got me to sign up in the first place. I used to chase the flashy promos and bonus bets a lot more, now I care way more about whether they limit quick, how painful the ID check is, if cashouts land without drama, and whether the app turns into a potato right before kickoff.
For me the biggest tell is what happens after a decent run. Plenty look great when you're just chucking on your weekend NRL or AFL bets, but once you start betting a bit more regularly you find out pretty quick who's decent and who's just there for rec punters. Same with markets too... some are sweet for racing, some are miles better for same game multis, some are alright pre-match but useless live.
Also keen to hear what people here actually rate these days for the boring stuff no one talks about enough - withdrawal speed, limits, support, odds movement, void rules, that sort of thing. Doesn't have to be a full essay, just who you've stuck with lately and why. Or who went to water on ya after a couple of wins haha.
Would be good to get a proper punter-to-punter thread going instead of the usual shiny homepage nonsense.