Been doing this properly for a couple of months now instead of just eyeballing odds and having a crack when something felt short. Basic idea was I make my own number first, then check the bookies after. If their price is longer than what I had, that’s the only time I even think about it.
Couple things stood out pretty quick. I’m betting way less, which was probably needed anyway... and most of the edge seems to come from being picky, not from some genius read. When I was chucking bets on every arvo I could always talk myself into a play. Hard to do that when you’ve already written your price down first.
The rough part is it feels slow and kind of dull at times, and the results can look rubbish for a while even if the process is fine. Had a run where I was getting decent closing numbers and still copping losses. Bit annoying, but it did stop me from binning the whole thing after one bad week.
I also reckon this works better in markets you actually follow heaps. For me the mainstream stuff gets trimmed pretty hard, so there’s not much room unless you’re really on top of injuries, line-ups, weather, all that. Lower profile comps and player markets felt a bit looser, though limits can be ordinary.
Biggest lesson so far: if you’re not tracking your bets, you’re basically guessing whether it’s doing anything. Once I started logging my price, the bookie price, close, and result, a few patterns jumped out straight away.
Anyway that’s my review on it so far. Not some magic ATM, just a more disciplined way to punt and probably better than chasing multis because they look juicy. Keen to hear how others here do it — do you make your own prices, use ratings, compare books, or just watch closing line movement and go from there?